im not sure abt best or worst about the movie cos the whole story was new. maybe not with hollywood movie calibre but definitely for any indian movie. its a new, brave and, i must say a successful attempt. all who thought John Abraham was a male bimbo(including me) will be proven wrong...cos hey...this guy has proven that he can act...it was very moving. he absorbed the character of Sam so well you cant tell that it is John...it is that all-american gutsy boy that Sam is. Katrina plays a gorgeous role of a friend, a lover, a wife and a mother...and has certainly done the role beautifully. so did the friend and of course the FBI...who is an amazing actor. it is a story based in New york abt a particular incident that happened a few years back and the toll it took on the world and these three friends whose lives were pretty much close to beautiful. very nicely taken....an eye opener actually...hats off to the director and the actors!

What I loved most: Performance, Screenplay

What I really hated: certain scenes were draggy

a must watch flick this summer. Wonderful performances by John Abraham, Katrina Kaif, and special mention for Neil Nitin Mukesh & Irrfan Khan. Simple story about 3 friends whose live takes a turn after Sept 11. Gripping and shocking climax. Emotions and reasoning behind untaking a certain path of life was conveyed perfect. Very realistic and simple story protrayed fantastically by the actors and director.

What I loved most: It ended

What I really hated: The fear that it wouldnt end

The movie focuses on Umer; a gulllible Indian screwup whos talent for messing up everything is used by the FBI when they ask him to infiltrate a terrorit group. In return Umer can call himself "an undercover FBI agent" All Umer has to do is be himself and every will be just fine! Oh and this is not a comedy